On Tumblr, I reblogged a post inviting people to ask my top five of anything.
Cinder_Quill asked me for my 'top 5 fictional characters who make the WORST decisions'. This was a pretty fun list to make, so I thought I'd reproduce my answer here!
Oh, man, I love so many characters who make bad decisions! I'm just going to pluck some out of the air.
I'm not sure whether your question was 'who are your five favourite characters who make terrible decisions?' or 'of your favourite characters, which five make the worst decisions?', so I'll give you two lists.
Five terrible decision-makers who I love, emphasis on 'who I love':- Sean Diaz from
Life Is Strange 2. Look, I cannot blame this kid for going on the run with his nine-year-old brother. He was panicking, the police were coming, and a police officer had just ruined his entire life, so naturally he was unwilling to stick around and encounter more of them. It was a deeply understandable decision, but it was nonetheless a decision that fucked a
lot of things up.
- Ellie from
The Last of Us. I started loving Ellie in the first game, which was before she started making really terrible decisions. But I still love her after her desperate 'if I kill enough people, I'll feel better, right? right???' quest of the second game, and that definitely means she qualifies for this list.
- Jack Shephard from
Lost. Jack is a grieving, angry, unstable mess who's been thrown into a leadership position when he's barely clinging on to any form of reason with his fingernails. He has a lot of intense feelings, a gigantic saviour complex, poor self-control and no ability to delegate. Everything he does is a) guaranteed to blow up in his face and b) absolutely fascinating to me.
- James Sunderland from
Silent Hill 2. Look, if your dead wife tells you to come to a town, and then the town is full of monsters, you turn around and leave. I feel like there was another big terrible decision he made too, but I can't - I can't quite remember. That's weird. I wish I had a recording or something to jog my memory.
- Light Yagami from
Death Note. Light is very smart, but he's also very proud, and he loves using his own intelligence to convince himself that the correct course of action
coincidentally happens to be the thing he really wants to do. Yes, if he kills these people in this way, it'll make him look suspicious. But that's what he wants! It's all part of his ingenious plan to catch L, and totally not just because he wants to send L a personal 'fuck you' message. The 'fuck you' is coincidental. This is a very smart move.
Five terrible decision-makers who I love, emphasis on 'terrible decision-makers':- Seifer Almasy from
Final Fantasy VIII. One of the first terrible decision-makers I ever developed a fondness for! Seifer, you can't assist an evil sorceress in taking over the world just because you think it's cool and romantic and you really want to show up your rival at school.
- WD Gaster from
zarla's
Undertale fancomic
Handplates. Gaster is an expert in doing terrible things while convincing himself that there's definitely, definitely no other course of action. He's awful and I love him.
- Chloe Price from
Life Is Strange. Chloe is an absolute disaster in a way I find refreshing from a female character. Playing
Life Is Strange is a struggle because I want Chloe to like me, but everything she wants me to do is terrible. I don't want to steal money or shoot people or hang up on my distraught friend, Chloe!
- Aaaaand Jack Shephard and Light Yagami again. Fascinating characters. I could watch them making ill-advised decisions all day.
Honourable mentions to the other characters who crossed my mind while I was working on these lists: Mike Munroe, Jeff Winger, Mondo Owada, Dr Cox, Keiichi Maebara, and Lightning 'look, I don't expect punching a god in the face to go well, but I reeeeeally want to punch this god in the face' Farron.
If you'd like to
ask my top five of anything in the comments, incidentally, go ahead!